Mostrando postagens com marcador ]. Mostrar todas as postagens
Mostrando postagens com marcador ]. Mostrar todas as postagens

quinta-feira, 5 de fevereiro de 2015

The Giver: An Unfair Society

The society in the Giver is without choice, governed by people who decide everything for you.  I have a strong opinion that this community is not exactly utopia.

In this society, there are no secrets.  In the morning, you are forced to tell your dreams, and in the afternoon, all your personal feelings.  That would be torture for me, and for pretty much anyone alive on earth today.  No matter how personal, how awkward, or how hard it is to explain, you must tell your family members what it is.  Think of your deepest, darkest secret.  Now, imagine you telling it to your family.  Imagine the leaders of your community knowing what it is.  Also, in the morning, sharing every one of your dreams.  No matter how crazy or embarrassing.  I didn't think it sounded appealing either.

The most important reason this society is a bad idea is the families.  Everyone is assigned a "mate," and later, two children, one boy and one girl.  You don't choose your husband or wife, and the children aren't even yours.  The children are collected from birthmothers, which is a job assigned to young women.  The babies are taken care of by Nurturers, and later they are assigned to a couple.  Another thing that makes these "families" undesirable, is that there are no animals.  Why would that affect families?  No animals means no pets.  If you have a pet, you understand what this means for these people.  Pets become a part of your life, and life without them isn't as good.  The people of the community don't even understand what an animal is, and that's just sad.  So, picture your happy family life with your assigned spouse, raising kids that aren't your own (and, by the way, you don't get to name them), and without your dog or cat (or turtle or bird, etc.).  If you ask me, it isn't much of a family at all.

sexta-feira, 4 de outubro de 2013

Two Voice Poem -- The Reflection



Voice 1:  Karara
Both
Voice 2:  Eric  #
Maha, why don’t you treat me well?
You aren’t a very good
Mother!
Can you please go away?
“From the day you came out as a girl
and not a boy, you have been a burden.”
(page 85)  Just because I’m a girl, doesn’t
 mean I’m worthless!
Why do you always think it’s me, just
 because I’m a boy!  April broke that plate!
“Karara, weave the wah-pu into baskets,
crush up the ay-ah-e-yah一the men need
 more for fishing tomorrow一and watch
your sister.  I’m taking Luka to the forest.”
 (page 38) Maha throws words and chores
and tasks galore at me, like I was a worthless slave.
“Get your dress shirt, your vest, your 
dress pants, your church shoes, your 
black pants, a belt.”  I have to 
get all that fancy clothes that I hate, 
and Heather and April just slip on a 
dress that they would wear every 
second of their whole lives anyway.
Time is frozen for me, trapped in
a huge loop of chores and tasks.
An endless pause that will never
stop until Luka passes his test.
I climb out of the back seat 
to get out and my mom yells “Hey!!
  Let your sisters out first!”, like the world
 would implode if I didn’t
Why does it matter that I am a
girl?
boy?
That doesn’t mean I’m any less
important.
free.
Because you know what?
We deserve equality because we are humans all the same.





In writing the Two Voice Poem, I had to make a poem that compares my life to Karara's life (from Bringing the Boy Home.  The learning targets I tried to aim for were:
  • I can write a poem that compares two perspectives
  • I can use specific and relevant evidence from the text in my writing
  • I can use figurative language and descriptions in my writing to create vivid pictures in my readers mind
I think that I met the first learning target, because I think I explained the differences between myself and Karara decently.I don't think I got the 3rd reading target, because a) No one has read it yet so I can't know what picture it paints, and b) I am not so great at writing poems.  Well, I was.  I used to not be able to do figurative language so well.  My similes and metaphors made no sense whatsoever.  But, after making this poem, I improved a bit in writing poems.I partly achieved the third learning target because I only used one quote, and only explained what Karara's life is like, not why.

I have only made a few poems before this in 5th or 4th grade.  I think That I might write some again on a day with no school, maybe a random day on vacation to show my parents/grandparents or something.


I think I did well on my use of figurative language in this poem.  I think my best use of figurative language is "Time is frozen for me, trapped in a huge loop of chores and tasks.  An endless pause that will never stop until Luka passes his test.", because that's three metaphors in 2 sentences, and they all make sense. I also think that I did good at comparing Karara and I. I used 2 quotes from the book, which made there be evidence, supporting my comparison.